Page 2 of 2

Re: Indicator Column Switch replacement

Posted: Wed Jan 06, 2016 12:38 pm
by cleverusername
You can just solder to the original loom, I have done it and I have had no problems. To be fair the stalk I had had the original wiring loom cutoff, so I had no choice.

Re: Indicator Column Switch replacement

Posted: Wed Jan 06, 2016 1:52 pm
by GrahamFountain
I could splice to the wires inside the cowling at the top of the column - solder or crimp. But considering how much advice there is about replacing these switches, and that I'm on my third or so, they're virtually a service item.

So I think I want to use connectors. I was, initially, looking for something to connect inside the cowling, and if there's space, I still might. But if it's easy enough to replace down to the original connectors, I think I'll at least look at that.

Graham

Re: Indicator Column Switch replacement

Posted: Wed Jan 06, 2016 9:44 pm
by cleverusername
GrahamFountain wrote:I could splice to the wires inside the cowling at the top of the column - solder or crimp. But considering how much advice there is about replacing these switches, and that I'm on my third or so, they're virtually a service item.

So I think I want to use connectors. I was, initially, looking for something to connect inside the cowling, and if there's space, I still might. But if it's easy enough to replace down to the original connectors, I think I'll at least look at that.
Why are yours wearing out so often? I have had one dodgy one, but that was due to the internals being damaged by the power requirements of headlights. Are your headlights set up with relays?

Re: Indicator Column Switch replacement

Posted: Wed Jan 06, 2016 11:34 pm
by xvivalve
To consider these as a service item is folly; they are of limited supply!

Re: Indicator Column Switch replacement

Posted: Thu Jan 07, 2016 11:15 am
by GrahamFountain
I'm pretty sure I'm not wrong in saying that there being so much advice on offer can only mean that many of you have already done this job. Sounds like some have done it many times more than once. Okay calling it a service item is a bit hyperbolic, but I've been referring to TR7 front wings as "virtually service items" for a very long time.

And I don't think I'm misusing the switch, other than by using it a lot. It's the indicator side that's the problem at the moment – though it has had a problem with the main beam right from the start: it sometimes doesn't switches over, and all the headlights go off. And it's been really very stiff on the indicators since day one. So it's just always been in need of replacing, but not annoying enough till now to get me moving. So in that case, the problem is replacing with an old one that was already bust.

The previous one was broken by a place that claimed to be a garage, doing the bottom coupling - don't ask why they were buggering with the switches in that job, they were probably looking for a third hand so they could find their ars*. I think I broke the one that was on, turning the switches over so the indicator switch is on the left and the wipers on the right - like most modern cars. As the TR7 (after about 79 y.m.) and the wife's car are both that way, it suits me much better. I did wonder about LHD switches, but have never seen a set, and it's a fairly easy modificatio once you get the hang.

As a matter of interest, I've that problem with the lights burning out the switch on the 7s, but only once in many, many miles.

Graham

Re: Indicator Column Switch replacement

Posted: Thu Jan 07, 2016 12:57 pm
by Toledo Man
The relays take the load off the headlight circuit which goes through the indocator stalk and it is known for it to burn out. I personally know of at least one person it has happened to (Mark, the previous owner of my Sprint). For me it started when a couple of my sealed beam units failed. The price of replacements (when you can get them) is ridiculous so I fitted a set of halogen headlights and relays are essential with halogens. It is a worthwhile upgrade even with sealed beams. My headlights are brighter, when it fails it won't cost a fortune to fix (just replace the bulb) and I won't have any electrical problems with the relays that I 've fitted. Just one more thing: The relays need to be fused (one fuse per relay. Some relays have a built-in fuse which simplifies the wiring) which will offer further protection. It is worth every penny for total peace of mind.

Going back to your indicator stalk, try some contact cleaner. It should help get it working properly again.

Re: Indicator Column Switch replacement

Posted: Thu Jan 07, 2016 5:04 pm
by GrahamFountain
No, contact cleaner won't fix it - the latching mechanism has gone on indicating right turns, and I have to hold it in contact. It does work while I do that, but it's a pain. And it works going left. But like I said, it's been a wrongun since fitting and it's undoubtedly a replacement or nowt.

Graham

Re: Indicator Column Switch replacement

Posted: Thu Jan 07, 2016 6:53 pm
by Toledo Man
Looks like a replacement is the only option. It is worth taking the time to fit it properly. Once you've removed the bolt for the adjustment clamp, the column can be lowered for easy access to the cover. I suggest that you take a look at page 15 of James647's resto thread HERE The photos show you how the upper steering column goes together along with the wiring for the ignition barrel and the wiper & indicator stalks. It was useful for me when I sorted out my loose adjuster clamp and correctly routed the wire for my indicator stalk.

Re: Indicator Column Switch replacement

Posted: Fri Jan 08, 2016 1:09 pm
by GrahamFountain
Thanks for the link- that was useful. I'd still like to understand how to get the column out with the dash in, i.e. just the woodwork unscrewed and lifted out the way. I know that's not as per the ROM. That's to knock the pin out of the clamp, etc. But I'm sure someone said it is possible to do it by unbolting the two support tubes from under the dash top and twisting it round, but I tried all the ways I could see, and it never came free. Do I have to remove those supports at both of their ends, dash and column?

Graham

Re: Indicator Column Switch replacement

Posted: Fri Jan 22, 2016 1:56 pm
by GrahamFountain
I meant to post this a little while ago, but was sidetracked.

The problem has simply gone away on its own, including the original problem with main beam. I'm guessing there was some crap or such in the switch mechanism that's now fallen out. But that's a guess. So my current plan, as nearly always, is to leave well alone.

But I do hate it when problems just up and fix themselves - I may never know what is was.

Graham

Re: Indicator Column Switch replacement

Posted: Sun Feb 25, 2018 2:07 pm
by Graham04
Are the new Lucas indicator switches on ebay any good? After driving mine around for a few weeks in the dark, it has melted the plastic around the dip wires. Of course now I realise it has been uprated to halogen headlights by the previous owner. So relays will be added before any replacement switch is fitted. They are just over £50. Just a bit dubious these days about anything listed as Lucas.