Page 1 of 2
water loss
Posted: Wed Jul 05, 2017 11:20 pm
by epcot_pete
My 1300fwd suffers with a on-going problem of overheating!
I have had the radiator re-cored and fitted an electric fan. After a run of about 5 miles and parked with engine switched off, the expansion bottle will over-flow with boiling water. After about 40 miles the bottle is empty! No signs of leakage, new distributer fitted and timing triple checked, MGB tempreture gauge fitted and averages 190 - 220 degrees - the existing gauge always reads just below hot, just been through MOT so no brakes binding, very poor getting up hills.
Am I right to think the head gasket has gone?
Appreciate any thoughts on the subject.
Pete
Re: water loss
Posted: Wed Jul 05, 2017 11:31 pm
by xvivalve
Sounds very much like it; have you done a compression test?
Re: water loss
Posted: Thu Jul 06, 2017 6:55 am
by Toledo Man
I've moved the thread here because it is a technical question.
Re: water loss
Posted: Thu Jul 06, 2017 7:46 am
by GTS290N
Re: water loss
Posted: Thu Jul 06, 2017 8:39 am
by James467
Never had the need nor desire to use these, even on the K. The heads on an OHV are relatively easy to pull so I'd just pull the head replace the gasket, that way you know you have have eliminated a problem.
The other thing is have you checked your expansion tank cap?
Re: water loss
Posted: Thu Jul 06, 2017 12:44 pm
by tony g
Are you sure the bottle and cap are holding pressure? If it cant pressurise it will lose from the overflow and gush out when switched off as you describe (pressure and temp rise slightly after the pump stops turning)
another cheap test is run the car til warm and quickly whip the plugs out and look for vapour coming out of the plug holes, which could indicate water in that pot. Plug colour may have a tinge of your antifreeze colour too.
Tony
Re: water loss
Posted: Thu Jul 06, 2017 1:02 pm
by Carledo
Worth checking/removing/replacing the thermostat as well, before ripping the head off.
Besides the lack of power climbing hills, are there any other symptoms like missfiring, difficult turnover at startup, signs of water in the oil (or vice versa)? Your normal running temperature is way in excess of what is ACTUALLY normal!
I dislike to suggest this and I know it's an iron headed car (so a less likely possibility) but your listed symptoms so far closely resemble those of a 1500 MkI Cortina (also with an iron head) that I once owned. It, like yours, was driveable for shortish runs so I ignored it for ages, having removed the thermostat entirely and flushed the cooling system to no discernible result. When I finally got fed up and pulled the head off, it had a large crack from the No3 cylinder combustion chamber to the adjacent water gallery. In those days, a second hand head at £5 from a scrapyard, plus a new head gasket cured it completely!
Steve
Re: water loss
Posted: Thu Jul 06, 2017 1:03 pm
by dollyman
possible airlock?? given it boils so quick??
Re: water loss
Posted: Thu Jul 06, 2017 3:41 pm
by Triumph1300
Start with basics, timing and mixture
Then move on to checking cooling system
Your overflow bottle isn't sealed in a 1300, the level will vary.
Re: water loss
Posted: Sun Jul 09, 2017 10:02 pm
by epcot_pete
Thank you all for your constructive comments.
I am going to go through all your ideas over the next few days and will report back then.
Thanks again
Pete
Re: water loss
Posted: Mon Jul 10, 2017 11:53 pm
by epcot_pete
Hi All,
Have checked:
Compression Test: 1-4 cylinders range from 105-115psi so seems ok to me.
Plug condition: Good and normal. Gap slightly big, so cleaned and reset.
New distributer fitted about 500 miles ago to eliminate overheating and improve performance.
Timing is about right. Not easy on 1300, but through road test adjustment I think it is about right.
Took thermostat out and back flushed system, water clear. Did not replace thermostat.
The water pump was replaced about 1 year ago.
Bled the system with valve on top at rear of head to ensure no air lock.
The oil level is constant and shows no signs of water.
Took car for a junction run at 70mph on M42 and ran normal, but normal road running with hills, the tempreture reached 212 degrees and when I got home the expansion bottle was overflowing.
Seems like the radiator is not cooling properly. I had the radiator re-cored last year because I thought it was blocked, which was confirmed when they took it apart. How can I check it is not blocked again, or that the core was not blocked during soldering?
Appreciate your thoughts.
Pete
Re: water loss
Posted: Tue Jul 11, 2017 1:16 am
by Carledo
You're not far from me Pete, could you bring it up to mine for a look? (Highley, South Shropshire) I don't have a pukka 1300 rad, but I have a 1500 Dolomite one we could probably jury rig to fit for test.
A crack in the head will not always show a drop in compression but could still be the cause. best to eliminate every other possibility first though!
Steve
Re: water loss
Posted: Tue Jul 11, 2017 7:35 am
by Triumph1300
Or alternatively, have a wander to Coventry, for advice, sympathy, and 1300 bits
Re: water loss
Posted: Tue Jul 11, 2017 8:13 am
by xvivalve
If this were a slant 4, I'd be checking to see if the water pump impeller was slipping on the shaft. You say your pump was replaced about a year ago; was it a reputable supplier? Can the impeller fail on a 1300 pump? What proof do you have that the coolant is circulating properly?
Re: water loss
Posted: Tue Jul 11, 2017 10:48 am
by Magenta Auto Sprint
I have had a similar water loss issue on my 1850 Auto this weekend.
Coming back from the Isle of Wight the temp gauge was going up, topped it up with ¼ litre of water but 7 miles later the same thing, and again 7 miles later.
I stopped at Liphook services and could find no signs of a leak, all the hoses are new and so is the radiator, no weeping from the water pump slot either.
I called the AA who pressure tested it, again nothing untoward was found. The AA concluded that it was probably the early stages of head gasket failure.
So I look forward to that job like a hole in the head.