Stainless steel head studs.
-
- Guest contributor
- Posts: 868
- Joined: Thu May 17, 2012 9:34 pm
Stainless steel head studs.
I see you can now get Stainless head studs for the Stag, and thus Dolomite 1850. Having been to a great deal of trouble last year to remove the head off mine, having non-corroding studs is appealing. Anyone used them? Any down sides? Thanks... Matt.
- yorkshire_spam
- Guest contributor
- Posts: 994
- Joined: Wed Nov 15, 2017 3:35 pm
- Location: Filey, North Yorkshire
Re: Stainless steel head studs.
I'm not sure stainless will solve the problem, can't you still get galvanic corrosion between aluminium alloys and stainless?
I could be wrong though?
I could be wrong though?
-
- Guest contributor
- Posts: 1034
- Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2009 11:41 pm
- Location: Silsoe, Beds
Re: Stainless steel head studs.
if you look at a galvanic corrosion chart, stainless steel and aluminium is worse than steel and aluminium.
- Attachments
-
- Galv table.png (90.64 KiB) Viewed 2079 times
1942 Willys Jeep
1960 1385 Austin Mini
1975 Dolomite Sprint Automatic
1973 Dolomite 1850 Automatic
1976 Dolomite 1300 (aka Lucky)
1960 1385 Austin Mini
1975 Dolomite Sprint Automatic
1973 Dolomite 1850 Automatic
1976 Dolomite 1300 (aka Lucky)
-
- Guest contributor
- Posts: 868
- Joined: Thu May 17, 2012 9:34 pm
Re: Stainless steel head studs.
Is the issue galvanic corrosion generally? Certainly the old studs on mine were heavily corroded and swollen, stainless would at least avoid this problem. Combine with some anti-seize compound for best protection?
Re: Stainless steel head studs.
It's almost common knowlegde that stainless steel and alloy don't work together. Putting an anti-seize compound or copaslib even makes it worse as it works as a conductor between the two. There are a lot of motorcycle restorers in the past that found out the nice stainless bolts used in the alloy enginehalves were falling out after years because of the threads had corroded out...matt of the vivas wrote: Is the issue galvanic corrosion generally? Certainly the old studs on mine were heavily corroded and swollen, stainless would at least avoid this problem. Combine with some anti-seize compound for best protection?
First lesson at the first class of the restorers school. Don't put stainless steel near alloy.
Jeroen
Classic Kabelboom Company. For all your wiring needs. http://www.classickabelboomcompany.com
-
- TDC Member
- Posts: 1793
- Joined: Mon Dec 12, 2016 9:53 pm
- Location: Harrow Middlesex
Re: Stainless steel head studs.
try ceramic grease
-
- Guest contributor
- Posts: 868
- Joined: Thu May 17, 2012 9:34 pm
Re: Stainless steel head studs.
Copaslip is not conductive?
-
- Guest contributor
- Posts: 868
- Joined: Thu May 17, 2012 9:34 pm
Re: Stainless steel head studs.
Thanks for the useful replies. And thanks Jeroen for the sarcasm...
I must have missed my "first lesson at car restorer school" then.
Copaslip is not even slightly conductive. It's insulative, that's its purpose. It's anti-seize compound.
I've used stainless bolts in alloy housings for years. Not had an issue. Possibly if you had salt water then it might corrode - but the anti-seize will keep that out of the threads?
I was hoping someone on here might have used the stainless studs and could comment on quality etc - not a load of theory.
As already stated - when I removed the head off mine, most of the problem was the original studs had swollen and corroded. The alloy of the head was not badly damaged. Surely the stainless studs will not corrode, at least avoiding this problem?
I must have missed my "first lesson at car restorer school" then.
Copaslip is not even slightly conductive. It's insulative, that's its purpose. It's anti-seize compound.
I've used stainless bolts in alloy housings for years. Not had an issue. Possibly if you had salt water then it might corrode - but the anti-seize will keep that out of the threads?
I was hoping someone on here might have used the stainless studs and could comment on quality etc - not a load of theory.
As already stated - when I removed the head off mine, most of the problem was the original studs had swollen and corroded. The alloy of the head was not badly damaged. Surely the stainless studs will not corrode, at least avoiding this problem?
- yorkshire_spam
- Guest contributor
- Posts: 994
- Joined: Wed Nov 15, 2017 3:35 pm
- Location: Filey, North Yorkshire
Re: Stainless steel head studs.
Sorry Matt, no personal experience of the stainless. I just used standard ones when I needed replacements. (I was exceptionally lucky taking the head off my 1850 and the studs came out and the head off ok)
Re: Stainless steel head studs.
That will be something intranslation. It conducts electrical current but maybe it's translated different. It's not an isolator between the stainless steel and alloy but will only speed up the corrosive process.matt of the vivas wrote:Copaslip is not conductive?
Jeroen
Classic Kabelboom Company. For all your wiring needs. http://www.classickabelboomcompany.com
Re: Stainless steel head studs.
Do they have the same tensile strength?
Some people are like Slinky's, they serve no real purpose in life but bring a smile to your face when you push them down the stairs.
-
- Guest contributor
- Posts: 1560
- Joined: Mon Dec 03, 2012 6:04 pm
Re: Stainless steel head studs.
Copper grease is definitely conductive because it has bits of copper in it, which is an excellent conductor.
To be honest I am not sure there is an easy answer to this. Even if stainless didn't galvanically react with aluminum, I would be worried about the tensile strength. You could use grease but would that affect the ability to correctly torque up the head?
I know that the Sprint has less problems with the head seizing on but I am not sure why that is.
To be honest I am not sure there is an easy answer to this. Even if stainless didn't galvanically react with aluminum, I would be worried about the tensile strength. You could use grease but would that affect the ability to correctly torque up the head?
I know that the Sprint has less problems with the head seizing on but I am not sure why that is.
Re: Stainless steel head studs.
£72.50 for five studs. Ouch.
Could you change these to bolts Like ARP.
That way they would wind out as being removed.
From the ARP site.
Stainless Steel
Ideally suited for many automotive and marine applications because stainless is tolerant of heat and virtually impervious to rust and corrosion. ARP “Stainless 300” and Custom 450 materials are specially alloyed for extra durability. Both are polished using a proprietary process to produce a beautiful finish. Tensile strength is typically rated at 170,000-190,000 psi
Are you really that worried about taking the head off at a later date.
Could you change these to bolts Like ARP.
That way they would wind out as being removed.
From the ARP site.
Stainless Steel
Ideally suited for many automotive and marine applications because stainless is tolerant of heat and virtually impervious to rust and corrosion. ARP “Stainless 300” and Custom 450 materials are specially alloyed for extra durability. Both are polished using a proprietary process to produce a beautiful finish. Tensile strength is typically rated at 170,000-190,000 psi
Are you really that worried about taking the head off at a later date.
2011 Mini Clubman John Cooper Works. S Daily Driver.
1980 Dolomite Sprint with a touch of BLTS
Balanced Lightened and Tweaked 13B Rotary and SsuperCharged.
Back in my possession 22 September 2019.
Rebuilding the Sprint time taken so far, 111Hrs@15/12/2020
212Hrs @31/12/2021
352 @ 28/11/2022
455Hrs @ 20/10/2023
565Hrs @ 07/12/2024
This is time taken at the Sprint not necessary time worked.
Member TDC no 0471
Project 13B Sprint now back on..
No Pistons No Cams how’s it gonna Run Brap Brap?
1980 Dolomite Sprint with a touch of BLTS
Balanced Lightened and Tweaked 13B Rotary and SsuperCharged.
Back in my possession 22 September 2019.
Rebuilding the Sprint time taken so far, 111Hrs@15/12/2020
212Hrs @31/12/2021
352 @ 28/11/2022
455Hrs @ 20/10/2023
565Hrs @ 07/12/2024
This is time taken at the Sprint not necessary time worked.
Member TDC no 0471
Project 13B Sprint now back on..
No Pistons No Cams how’s it gonna Run Brap Brap?
-
- TDC Member
- Posts: 1793
- Joined: Mon Dec 12, 2016 9:53 pm
- Location: Harrow Middlesex
Re: Stainless steel head studs.
These stainless steel head studs,are aircraft gradematt of the vivas wrote: ↑Sat Nov 20, 2021 8:46 pm Thanks for the useful replies. And thanks Jeroen for the sarcasm...
I must have missed my "first lesson at car restorer school" then.
Copaslip is not even slightly conductive. It's insulative, that's its purpose. It's anti-seize compound.
I've used stainless bolts in alloy housings for years. Not had an issue. Possibly if you had salt water then it might corrode - but the anti-seize will keep that out of the threads?
I was hoping someone on here might have used the stainless studs and could comment on quality etc - not a load of theory.
As already stated - when I removed the head off mine, most of the problem was the original studs had swollen and corroded. The alloy of the head was not badly damaged. Surely the stainless studs will not corrode, at least avoiding this problem?
-
- TDC Member
- Posts: 1793
- Joined: Mon Dec 12, 2016 9:53 pm
- Location: Harrow Middlesex
Re: Stainless steel head studs.
The sprint doesnt have the same problems because the studs are submerged in oilcleverusername wrote: ↑Sun Nov 21, 2021 9:24 am Copper grease is definitely conductive because it has bits of copper in it, which is an excellent conductor.
To be honest I am not sure there is an easy answer to this. Even if stainless didn't galvanically react with aluminum, I would be worried about the tensile strength. You could use grease but would that affect the ability to correctly torque up the head?
I know that the Sprint has less problems with the head seizing on but I am not sure why that is.
Dave